CRAFTING ENGAGING DIALOGUE WITH AI - A FICTION WRITER’S GUIDE [Post 13-A]

AI Can Help Your Characters Speak Authentically

Feb 04, 2025

(To read the free posts in chronological order, visit our Table of Contents page.)

(To read the paid posts in chronological order, visit our Advanced Table of Contents page.)

Natural, compelling dialogue can make or break a story. When characters speak authentically, readers become immersed in your fictional world. But creating distinct voices for different characters while advancing your plot through conversation isn’t always easy. Artificial intelligence can help you develop, test, and refine your dialogue, making character interactions more dynamic and purposeful.

In this lesson, we’ll explore how AI can assist with dialogue creation while maintaining your authentic storytelling voice.

Understanding Dialogue: The Basics

Good dialogue does more than just convey information—it reveals character personalities, moves the story forward, and builds relationships between characters. While dialogue should feel natural, it needs to be more focused than real-life conversation, eliminating the repetition and filler that make actual talks meander.

One key principle is that each character should have their own distinct way of speaking, reflecting their background, current emotional state, and relationship with others. This helps readers distinguish between characters and understand them better.

A common problem some writers make is making all characters sound the same, often mirroring the author’s own voice. AI can help you develop and maintain distinct speech patterns for each character, making conversations more engaging and authentic.

Let’s see how AI can help you create more natural and effective dialogue.

AI in Action: A Simple Dialogue Example

MY PROMPT:

Claude, help me write dialogue between two characters discussing plans for dinner. Character 1 is Tom, an accountant who values efficiency. Character 2 is Maria, a creative chef who’s passionate about food. Include their different approaches to the same situation.

CLAUDE’S RESPONSE:

“Sure, here’s their dialogue:

‘Where should we grab dinner?’ Tom checked his watch. ‘I’ve got forty-five minutes before my client meeting.’

‘Oh! I just discovered this amazing little Vietnamese place,’ Maria’s eyes lit up. ‘The chef makes his own rice noodles fresh every morning. You can actually watch him—’

‘Is it nearby? And do they take reservations?’

‘Well, it’s about twenty minutes away, but trust me, the pho alone is worth the drive. They simmer the broth for—’

‘That doesn’t leave much time to eat.’ Tom pulled out his phone. ‘There’s a new place two blocks over with good reviews. Four-star efficiency rating.’

Maria sighed. ‘You and your efficiency ratings. Food isn’t just fuel, Tom. It’s an experience.’”

FOLLOW-UP PROMPT:

Could you show me the same scene but with added internal thoughts from Tom’s perspective?

CLAUDE’S RESPONSE:

“Here’s the scene with Tom’s internal thoughts:

‘Where should we grab dinner?’ Tom checked his watch. Forty-three minutes until the Wilson account meeting. ‘I’ve got forty-five minutes before my client meeting.’

‘Oh! I just discovered this amazing little Vietnamese place,’ Maria’s eyes lit up. Here we go again, Tom thought. Another of her culinary adventures. ‘The chef makes his own rice noodles fresh every morning. You can actually watch him—’

‘Is it nearby? And do they take reservations?’ Please say yes to both.

‘Well, it’s about twenty minutes away, but trust me, the pho alone is worth the drive. They simmer the broth for—’

‘That doesn’t leave much time to eat.’ Tom pulled out his phone, already knowing this was going nowhere good. ‘There’s a new place two blocks over with good reviews. Four-star efficiency rating.’

Maria sighed. ‘You and your efficiency ratings. Food isn’t just fuel, Tom. It’s an experience.’

He bit back his response about experiences not impressing clients who are kept waiting.”

This example shows how characters’ different values and personalities can create natural conflict and reveal character through dialogue. Let’s explore how to apply these principles to your own writing.

How to Use Claude AI to Help You With Dialogue

Whether you’re writing new scenes or revising existing dialogue, AI can help you create more authentic conversations between your characters.

A. AI Implementation

- Use AI to develop distinct speech patterns for each character

- Test different emotional tones in the same conversation

- Ask Claude to add internal thoughts and reactions

- Create dialogue that reveals character traits

- Balance verbal and non-verbal communication

B. Action Items

1. Choose a dialogue scene to develop

2. List each character’s key traits and speaking style

3. Identify places where voices sound too similar

4. Note where dialogue could reveal more about characters

5. Ask Claude to help you remedy these issues

C. Success Markers

You know you’ve been successful when:

- Characters have distinct voices

- The dialogue moves the story forward

- Conversations feel natural but purposeful

- Non-verbal elements support the dialogue

- Each exchange reveals something about the characters

Creating authentic dialogue takes practice, but with Claude AI’s assistance, you can develop conversations that engage readers and bring your characters to life. Remember that AI is a tool to enhance your creativity, not replace your unique voice as a writer.

Conclusion

Crafting effective dialogue is a crucial skill for fiction writers. By using AI to help develop distinct character voices, test different approaches, and refine conversations, you can create more engaging and authentic dialogue that serves your story while maintaining your creative vision.

Coming Up Next

Thursday’s Paid Post: Advanced Dialogue Techniques - Learn sophisticated methods for crafting subtext, managing multiple speakers, and creating dialogue that operates on multiple levels. Plus, get downloadable resources, including a dialogue development worksheet and character voice template.

Next Tuesday: Building Tension Through Subplots - Discover how AI can help you weave compelling subplots that add depth and intrigue to your story. We’ll explore how to create secondary storylines that complement your main plot, develop supporting character arcs, and maintain multiple narrative threads without losing focus. Whether you’re writing a complex family saga or adding romantic tension to your mystery novel, you’ll learn practical techniques for using AI to enhance your story’s complexity while keeping readers engaged. Join us to unlock the power of subplots in your fiction.

Ready to Use AI to Help You with Dialogue?

Here’s what you can do right now:

1. If you haven’t done so, sign up for Claude AI 3.5 Sonnet Pro at Anthropic’s website. You want the option that says “Meet Claude 3.5 Sonnet.”

2. Subscribe for FREE to this newsletter if you haven’t already: Don’t miss out on future tips and tricks for using AI to write better and faster. Hit the subscribe button below to get The Writer’s AI Companion newsletter delivered straight to your inbox.

3. Share your thoughts: What’s your most significant (or current) writing challenge? Comment below and tell me what AI writing tips you’d like to see in future newsletters.

4. Spread the word: Do you know a fellow writer who could use a brainstorming partner? Please share this newsletter with them, and let’s grow our AI writing community together.

Until next time, let’s stay productive and creative,

-Elaine

P.S. Feel free to email me at Elaine@TheWrittenLink.com. Please put “Companion” in the subject line.